Dirty Secret
Dirty Secret: A Daughter Comes Clean About Her Mother’s Compulsive Hoarding by Jessie Sholl
Memoir, Mental Health, Behavior Sciences (2010)
Last Page… March 18th, 2011 [13/50]
Last Impression: ⚘⚘⚘
There are hoarders in my family - not messy ones, but certainly pack-rat obsessive ones. My grandfather cleans every bottle of peanut butter, every container of baby food, and is constantly searching the clearance aisle to see if there is anything that he “may” need one day in the future. I think at last count, he had close to a thousand dollars in bills for various storage units a month. That is the same as renting a decent apartment! And still there are stacks everywhere in his house - rambling, cluttered stacks of things he can’t be parted with, of things he may need someday, of things he doesn’t even remember.
To his credit, everything is extremely neat and clean - he used to be the administrator of a hospital cleaning service, so he knows how to keep things clean… but he keeps a lot of things, and they all seem to weigh him down with each passing month.
Thankfully, the effect has been diluted through my family line. My mother keeps far more than she needs, for sure, but most of that is scrapbook stuff and can actually be used for art. As for me? I have a nice collection of things, but I purge regularly - at least twice a year - and only buy as many shoes as I need (read: three pairs) among other things.
So it was with interest in my family history and personal awareness of the effects that mess and clutter can have on your life that I picked up Dirty Secret and read it over Spring Break. On some level the book wasn’t what I thought it was going to be - there was no real resolution, no real sense of character growth… but in this case, the characters were real people and this was a fragment of a real, evolving story of their lives. And fragmented it certainly was.
Part expose into the mentality of hoarding, part coming of age, part mommy issues and all biography, Dirty Secret was decent enough as a light read, but leaves the reader with little or no resolution. There have been no lasting changes and not even any great acceptance of the state of things - simply episode after episode, with drama expressed through active scenes that somehow lacked emotional commitment. A light read, but there were no lessons to take away, no message, no empowering seeds of thought…
The author was certainly honest and straight-forward in presenting how frustrated her life had been, but I wonder if she has yet approached her own resolution and growth with these areas of her life. Until she gets there, how can she properly finish such a story…? In the state it is, the story is interesting, but lacking of real content or resolution.